Korean labor authorities dismissed Hani's harassment claims against HYBE, stating she does not qualify as a worker under labor laws.
November/20/2024 10:55
Hani (real name: Hani Pam) of NewJeans raised harassment within HYBE, and the Korean Ministry of Employment concluded it was 'not applicable.' Today (20th), the Ministry of Employment revealed that 'the Seoul Western Employment Agency determined it difficult to define Hani Pam as a worker under labor standards law regarding the workplace harassment she raised with the Ministry of Employment, leading to administrative closure.' In September, she claimed during a YouTube live stream, 'While waiting in the hallway of the HYBE building, I greeted passing artists and managers, but the manager told me to 'ignore her' right in front of me.' The Western Agency clarified regarding this decision that 'due to the nature of the management contract Hani Pam entered into, it is difficult to define her as a worker under labor standards law,' stating, 'In Hani's case, both parties are equal contracting parties, and they merely have a relationship of fulfilling contractual obligations, making it hard to say there was company direction or supervision.' Furthermore, they pointed out that internal norms, systems, and regulations applicable to regular employees do not apply, that there are no set working hours or locations, making it difficult to determine working hours, and that costs necessary for entertainment activities are jointly borne by the company and Hani. Finally, the Western Agency referred to a Supreme Court ruling from September 2019, which indicated that the nature of exclusive contracts for entertainers falls under civil law's mandate or similar unnamed contracts, emphasizing that it is hard to see Hani as a worker under labor standards law. Previously, Hani attended a National Assembly audit as a reference on October 15 in Yeouido, Seoul. She said, 'Today is a place to talk about harassment and bullying within the company. I have thought a lot since experiencing this. Of course, I know there is no law that can solve everything in this world, but if we respect each other as humans, I believe there will be no harassment or bullying,' showing moments of trembling voice and tears.
Related Articles
NewJeans has announced their return to ADOR, drawing major media attention in Japan. This marks a significant development after their contract termination last November. Members Minji, Hani, and Danielle expressed their intent to return, although through a legal representative. Their influence in Japan is substantial, evidenced by their chart-topping hits and record-breaking performances.
NewJeans members have officially announced their return to ADOR after individual meetings and discussions about their future. The decision comes nearly a year after a unilateral contract termination. While two members returned after careful consideration, the remaining three expressed their intent to return, leading to mixed reactions from fans.
Min Heejin, former head of ADOR, supports NewJeans' return, highlighting the members' courage and the importance of their unity. She expresses gratitude to fans for their support and hopes for the members' happiness and growth. Heejin also clarifies that her ongoing lawsuit with HYBE is unrelated to NewJeans.
NewJeans members Hae-rin and Hae-in confirmed their return to ADOR after careful consideration. Following this, Minji, Hani, and Daniel also expressed their intent to return, but their announcement was made without prior consultation with ADOR, leading to speculation about their future activities. ADOR is currently verifying the intentions behind their return.
NewJeans members Minji, Hani, and Danielle have announced their intention to return to ADOR, confirming their decision after careful discussions. This follows Hae-rin and Hae-in's earlier announcements. The group had previously declared a contract dispute with ADOR, but now all five members may resume activities together after nearly a year.
NewJeans members Hae-rin and Hae-in have decided to continue their activities with ADOR, respecting a court ruling regarding their contract. ADOR expressed commitment to support them in their entertainment activities and requested fans to refrain from speculation about the members' situation.
A legal battle escalated between ADOR and the Dolphin Kidnapping Gang over music video rights, with Min Hee-jin testifying in court. The dispute arose after director Shin Woo-seok uploaded a director's cut of 'ETA' to his YouTube channel without permission. ADOR claims this harmed their interests, while Min argues it’s a common industry practice. The court is examining the validity of claims regarding management responsibilities and contract practices.
NewJeans lost a lawsuit against ADOR regarding their exclusive contract, with lawyers indicating a slim chance of winning an appeal. The court ruled that there was no valid reason to terminate the contract. If NewJeans prolongs the case, they may not be able to perform until 2027. ADOR expressed gratitude for the ruling, while NewJeans plans to appeal, citing a complete breakdown of trust with ADOR.
SOURCE MUSIC has countered former ADOR head Min Hee-jin's claims in a lawsuit regarding NewJeans. They presented evidence in court, including videos of the member selection process, to refute her statements about the group's formation and HYBE's commitments. Min Hee-jin is also involved in a separate lawsuit with BELIFT LAB over similar allegations.
Daniel from NewJeans participated in a 10K marathon, finishing with a personal best of 46 minutes. He shared a moment with former marathon runner Lee Young-jin. Meanwhile, NewJeans lost a lawsuit against ADOR regarding their exclusive contract, with the court ruling that the contract remains valid despite their claims.
